COVID-19 Update and Resources: Learn More

Smart Debt

by Dave Pratt

A lot of people tell me that they want to be “debt free.” They are tired of making big interest payments on land, livestock, machinery and their operating note. They have had too many sleepless nights worrying about making the next payment. They believe that if they didn’t have to borrow money they would be more profitable and financially secure.  

But the proper use of debt makes us more profitable, not less. And being debt free doesn’t make us financially secure. In fact, for most of us, short of winning the lottery, the appropriate use of debt is our only realistic path to financial security.

The problem isn’t debt, it’s our misuse of debt. The two most common ways we misuse debt are:

  1. We put finance first and economics a distant second
  2. We use debt on the wrong things.

Using debt effectively begins with understanding the difference between economics and finance. It boils down to this: In economics we ask, “Is this profitable?” In finance we ask, “Can I afford to do it?” If we are going to be smart about our use of debt, economics must come first. If it isn’t profitable you don’t have to worry about how you’ll pay for it, because you shouldn’t do it in the first place. 

When RFP grads evaluate the profitability of a livestock enterprise they include opportunity interest on the herd as a direct cost in the calculation. If the enterprise has a healthy gross margin it tells us that borrowing money to expand the herd will increase profit. If we haven’t included opportunity interest in our calculation we can’t be sure if expanding the herd is a good idea. 

The other problem is that people use debt on the wrong things. There are two primary places where we put money in our businesses: fixed assets and working capital. Simply put, fixed assets are things we intend to keep (e.g. land, cows, infrastructure, vehicles, equipment). Working capital is the money tied up in things we intend to sell (e.g. calves).  Most of us have most of our money invested in fixed assets. This is the biggest financial problem in agriculture. It’s a problem because when most of our money is tied up in things we intend to keep, we have relatively little to sell and generate very little income relative to the value of our assets. Making matters worse, a lot of the income that we do create gets spent maintaining the fixed assets. That’s why most ranchers are wealthy on their balance sheet and broke in their bank account.

Borrowing to buy fixed assets may be a smart long-term investment strategy, but it might cause you to go belly-up in the short term.   We’d be better off to use debt to buy assets that directly produce income.

We shouldn’t be afraid to borrow money, provided the economics of our enterprise is rock-solid and we use the borrowed money to buy income producing assets.

One Response to “Smart Debt”

June 13, 2018 at 10:24 am, james coffelt said:

Liquidity is key: Cash, stocks, Livestock, are liquid. Cash is cash, stocks can be sold in an hour, livestock sold in a week. Safe debt is having equal or higher, liquid assets to debt, and nothing could sink the ship.

If cash is needed in a downturn, you cannot get it, so, the fixed assets in land, and equipment at a minimum should be financed.

The liquidity in the above, permits surviving downturns, making all payments and wait it out, and provides liquidity to make deals, when there is blood in the streets.


Leave a Reply to james coffelt Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *